Key Takeaways
- Almost every offer has room; not asking leaves money on the table.
- Negotiate in writing when you want time to be precise and keep a record.
- Anchor to market data and your value, never to personal need.
- Stay warm and enthusiastic — you are joining these people next week.
You Can Almost Always Ask
Employers expect a counter and usually build in room for one. A polite, well-reasoned ask rarely costs you an offer that was genuinely coming — companies do not rescind over a respectful negotiation. The downside is small; the upside compounds over every future raise, which is calculated from your starting number.
Why Email Works
Email lets you choose your words carefully, cite numbers precisely, and avoid being pressured into an on-the-spot yes. It also creates a paper trail of what was agreed. If they call to negotiate live, it is fine to say, "I'd love to put my thoughts together and send them over this afternoon."
The Counteroffer Script
Hi [Name],
Thank you so much for the offer — I'm genuinely excited about joining [Company] and the [Role]. I've done some research on comparable roles, and based on the market and the experience I bring in [specific area], I was hoping we could get the base closer to [your number].
I'm confident I'll [specific value you'll deliver], and I want to start on the right footing for both of us. Is there flexibility on the base? I'm also happy to discuss [signing bonus / equity / start date] if that's easier to move.
Either way, I'm looking forward to it and grateful for the opportunity.
Best, [Your Name]
Anchor to Value, Not Need
- Do: cite market rates, your relevant experience, and specific results you will deliver.
- Do not: mention rent, loans, or another job's cost of living. Personal need is not the employer's lever, and it weakens your position.
Give one clear number, slightly above your target, so there is room to meet in the middle.
Negotiate Beyond Base Salary
If base is capped, other levers often have room: signing bonus, equity, remote flexibility, extra PTO, a earlier review date, or a title bump. Ask which pieces are flexible: "If the base is fixed, is there room on the signing bonus or start date?"
If They Say No
Accept gracefully and stay positive: "Completely understand — I'm still very happy to accept, and I look forward to starting." A firm no on money is not a reason to sour the relationship you are about to build.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will negotiating make them rescind the offer?
Very rarely, if you are respectful and reasonable. Companies expect a counter; a polite ask is normal and professional.
How much higher should I counter?
Aim 5–15% above the offer, anchored to real market data, so there is room to settle near your actual target.
Should I negotiate if the offer is already great?
You can still ask once, warmly. If it is genuinely strong and you are thrilled, it is also fine to accept — trust your read of the situation.
SS




